Chad Hetherington

Benötigen Sie Marketing-Hilfe? Kontaktieren Sie Brafton hier.

Email is a unique marketing channel in that it gives businesses a direct line to their customers, mostly without the influence of overly tuned algorithms like on social media or search. But it also offers something that marketers don’t always take full advantage of: an unmatched opportunity to learn what customers actually want.

During our recent webinar, Brafton’s Associate Director of Email Marketing, Bianca Baker, and Senior Global VP of Customer Experience, Tricia Calder, explored how marketers can use email to challenge assumptions, experiment with messaging and better understand the psychology behind customer decisions.

They got some great questions from attendees about testing, interpreting data, demonstrating ROI and turning customer insights into more effective campaigns. Bianca and Tricia answered a few of these questions live, but we’ll dive into each audience question individually here:

1. How Do You Approach Testing With a Smaller Audience?

It can be more difficult to draw definitive conclusions from a smaller audience, but that doesn’t mean you still can’t learn something valuable from email testing. It just means you need to be more deliberate about what you test and how you interpret the results.

Say you have 3,000 contacts; dividing your database into several small segments can make it difficult to draw reliable conclusions, particularly when measuring actions like purchases or demo requests.

Start with one meaningful question and keep your experiment simple.

For example, suppose you’re unsure whether your audience cares more about saving time or reducing costs. You could test two versions of an email, each emphasizing one of those benefits, while keeping the offer, call to action and other elements consistent. Then look at the results over time.

A single experiment with a small audience might not produce statistically significant results. An inconclusive result isn’t a failed experiment, though — it just means you don’t have enough evidence quite yet to declare a winner.

You can repeat the experiment across future campaigns, look for consistent patterns and supplement the findings with customer conversations or other available data.

The key is to match your conclusions to the strength of your evidence. A small test might give you a promising hypothesis worth investigating, even if it isn’t enough to justify sweeping changes to your marketing strategy.

2. How Do You Decide What To Test First?

With so many things to test, from subject lines and send times to messaging and segmentation, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Our recommendation is to start with what’s worth learning, rather than what’s easiest to test.

Think about the assumptions your marketing strategy currently relies on. That could be notions like:

  • Customers choose our product primarily because it saves time.
  • Price is the biggest objection preventing prospects from buying.
  • Decision-makers and everyday users care about the same product benefits.

How confident are you that these assumptions are true? And what would happen if they weren’t?

During the webinar, Bianca and Tricia introduced a simple prioritization framework based on two factors:

  1. Business importance: How much of your marketing strategy depends on this assumption?
  2. Uncertainty: How little evidence do you actually have to support it?

Assumptions that are highly important but supported by little evidence are generally the best candidates for testing. From there, consider whether email can realistically help answer the question and whether the result could change a meaningful business decision.

For example, testing whether customers prioritize accuracy over efficiency could inform your website positioning, sales messaging and future advertising campaigns. That’s potentially much more valuable than discovering which button color generates a few additional clicks.

Pick one important assumption, develop a competing hypothesis and design an experiment to investigate it. You don’t need to test everything at once.

3. How Can I Clearly Show the Connection Between Email and Revenue to Executives?

One way to strengthen the business case for email is to expand the conversation beyond campaign performance. Email has two important jobs:

  1. Send messages that generate engagement, conversions and revenue.
  2. Help the business learn something valuable about its customers.

The first is relatively familiar, but the second can easily be overlooked.

Of course, connecting email to revenue is still important. Integrating email performance with website analytics and CRM data can help reveal how campaigns contribute to qualified leads, sales opportunities, purchases and customer retention.

But email can also help answer questions that influence decisions across the business.

Here’s an example we shared during the webinar:

For one of Brafton’s e-commerce apparel clients, we tested two approaches to promoting a sale. One email displayed the discounted prices directly, while the other encouraged recipients to explore the sale.

The second approach generated more clicks and larger orders.

One possible explanation was curiosity: By leaving something to discover, the email gave recipients another reason to explore. That was a hypothesis, not a proven explanation of their motivation. The findings subsequently informed creative direction for advertising and paid social.

In other words, a relatively inexpensive email experiment helped inform decisions about more expensive marketing channels. That’s a compelling way to reposition email with leadership.

Rather than simply reporting how many people opened or clicked an email, explain what the campaign revealed about customers, what decisions those insights informed and whether the resulting changes improved business outcomes.

4. What’s the Biggest Mistake Marketers Make When Interpreting Email Data?

One of the biggest mistakes is treating customer behavior as definitive proof of motivation.

A click tells you someone was interested enough to take action, but it doesn’t necessarily tell you why. And an email that generates the most clicks isn’t automatically the one that delivers the greatest business value.

During the webinar, Bianca and Tricia explored a hypothetical experiment involving two versions of an email promoting reporting software. One emphasized efficiency and time savings, and the other focused on accuracy and confidence in reporting:

MetricEfficiency EmailAccuracy Email
Emails delivered4,0004,000
Clicks232168
Pricing page visits6174
Demo requests1422
Sales-qualified opportunities59

If we judged the experiment on clicks alone, the efficiency message would win.

But if the primary objective was generating demo requests, the accuracy message looks more promising.

There’s an important catch, though: The difference in demo requests wasn’t statistically significant. With only 36 demo requests across both groups, there wasn’t enough evidence to confidently conclude that the accuracy message was better at generating demos.

Does that make the finding useless? No, because it still provides something worth investigating further.

Perhaps accuracy matters more to decision-makers, while efficiency attracts earlier-stage interest. Or, perhaps the accuracy email simply had more compelling copy. The next step would be to investigate those possibilities through additional experiments, segmentation analysis or customer conversations.

All that to say, decide what success looks like before running a test, and don’t confuse observed behavior with an explanation of why it happened.

5. How Often Should We Be Auditing Our Email Campaigns?

Rather than treating email auditing as a one-time exercise, it’s useful to build regular reviews into your marketing process. The depth of those reviews can vary depending on what you’re trying to learn:

  • After individual campaigns: Review performance against your intended outcome and note anything unexpected.
  • Monthly: Look for patterns across campaigns, audience segments and automated workflows.
  • Quarterly: Revisit the assumptions guiding your email strategy and identify new questions worth testing.
  • Annually: Conduct a broader review of email performance, list health, segmentation, automation and contribution to business goals.

The quarterly review is particularly valuable from a customer intelligence perspective. Ask whether the beliefs guiding your messaging and targeting are still supported by evidence. Have customer priorities changed? Are certain segments behaving differently than expected? Have recent experiments challenged any longstanding assumptions?

This doesn’t need to be complicated, either. Document what you tested, why you tested it, what happened, how confident you are in the result and what you plan to do next. An audit should lead to action.

6. What Should a Company Do When Customer Behavior Contradicts What Its Sales Team or Leadership Believes Customers Want?

Investigate the contradiction before deciding what it means.

Sales teams and business leaders often have valuable firsthand knowledge of customers. But that knowledge can also be shaped by the people they interact with most frequently.

If existing customers regularly ask about AI capabilities, a business might reasonably conclude that AI is a major purchasing priority. So, it starts emphasizing AI in its marketing, attracts more AI-focused prospects and receives even more inquiries about AI.

That creates a feedback loop in which the marketing attracts customers who reinforce the original assumption. Meanwhile, a potentially much larger audience with different priorities may be going unnoticed.

Email can help uncover these blind spots, but an unexpected result shouldn’t automatically trigger a major strategic change.

Instead, consider several possible explanations.

If customers respond more strongly to messaging about accuracy than efficiency, for example, is that because accuracy is genuinely more important? Does it matter more to a particular stakeholder? Is it more relevant at a certain buying stage? Or was one version of the email simply better written?

Each explanation suggests a different next step. You might review sales notes, compare engagement across lifecycle stages, interview customers or repeat the experiment with different messaging.

During the webinar, Bianca and Tricia emphasized the importance of matching the size of a business decision to the strength of the evidence supporting it.

A promising email result might justify testing a new landing page headline, but it probably doesn’t justify rewriting your entire website or repositioning your brand.

For larger decisions, look for consistent findings across multiple sources, including email experiments, website behavior, sales conversations and customer research.

7. Do You Have Advice for Optimizing a HubSpot Drip Campaign To Nurture Contacts?

Yes! Start by asking whether your drip campaign reflects how contacts actually move through the buying process. A common approach to nurturing is to build a sequence of emails, schedule them at predetermined intervals and send everyone through roughly the same journey.

That can work, but it doesn’t always account for differences in customer needs, motivations or buying readiness.

HubSpot offers opportunities to make nurturing more responsive through segmentation, behavioral triggers and workflow automation.

Here are a few places to focus:

  • Review your segmentation: Job titles, industries and lifecycle stages are useful starting points, but consider what you know about the problems contacts are trying to solve and the outcomes they care about.
  • Give each email a clear purpose: An early message might address a common challenge, while later emails could provide case studies, product comparisons or opportunities to speak with sales.
  • Use behavior to inform next steps: Website visits, content downloads, form submissions and other qualifying actions can help determine when contacts should receive different messages or move into another workflow.
  • Define meaningful conversion goals: Rather than optimizing solely for clicks, consider whether the sequence generates qualified inquiries, demo requests or sales opportunities.
  • Review workflow performance regularly: Look for points where contacts disengage, stall or take unexpected actions.

It’s also worth testing the assumptions behind the sequence itself. For example, does someone who downloads an educational guide necessarily want a product demonstration next? Or would another resource addressing a related concern be more useful?

The best nurturing workflows respond to what the business is learning about those contacts along the way.

8. How Do We Write Emails That Are Attractive to Customers and Get Them Excited To Buy Our Products?

Start with the problem your customers are trying to solve, rather than the product you’re trying to sell.

A useful example from the webinar involved the famous milkshake study associated with Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen.

A fast-food chain wanted to sell more milkshakes. Initially, it asked customers how the product could be improved, focusing on characteristics like flavor, consistency and price.

But observing when and how people purchased milkshakes revealed that nearly half were sold before 8:30 a.m., often to commuters who purchased nothing else.

These customers weren’t necessarily looking for a better milkshake. They wanted something convenient that would make a long commute more enjoyable.

The same product served a completely different purpose for parents buying their children an afternoon treat.

The lesson applies directly to email marketing. Customers don’t necessarily buy products because of the features businesses consider most impressive. They buy them because those products help accomplish something important in a particular situation.

So, when writing promotional emails, consider:

  • What problem is the recipient trying to solve?
  • What outcome matters most to them?
  • What might prevent them from making a purchase?
  • What evidence would help them feel confident taking the next step?

Then build the message around those considerations.

Make Every Email Campaign an Opportunity To Learn

One of the biggest takeaways from Bianca and Tricia’s discussion was that every email campaign should teach marketers something new.

Despite how complex email can seem, creating learning opportunities doesn’t require a sophisticated testing program or an enormous contact database. Just identify an assumption worth challenging, design a fair experiment and think critically and creatively about what the results actually tell you.

Over time, those small investigations can help improve everything from email messaging and segmentation to sales strategy, customer experience and broader marketing investments.

Missed the webinar? Watch it on-demand at your convenience right here: